The Strength of Titanium For The Navy

From the Office of Naval Research

Steel may have met its match.

An Office of Naval Research  (ONR)-funded project will produce a full-size ship hull section made entirely with marine grade titanium using a welding innovation that could help bring titanium into future Navy ship construction.

The contractor team building this section recently completed the industry’s longest friction-stir titanium alloy welds and aims to complete the ship hull section this summer. Friction stir welds more than 17 feet long joined the titanium alloy plates for the section’s deck.

“This fast, effective friction stir weld technique is now an affordable manufacturing process that takes advantage of titanium’s properties,” said Kelly Cooper, the program officer managing the project for ONR’s Sea Warfare and Weapons Department .

What it means for the Navy

 Titanium  metal and its alloys are desirable materials for ship hulls and other structures because of their high strength, light weight and corrosion-resistance. If constructed in titanium, Navy ships would have lighter weight for the same size—allowing for a bigger payload—and virtually no corrosion. But because titanium costs up to nine times more than steel and is technically difficult and expensive to manufacture into marine vessel hulls, it has been avoided by the shipbuilding industry.

But perhaps not for much longer.

Researchers at the University of New Orleans School of Naval Architecture  and Textron Marine and Land Systems  are demonstrating the feasibility of manufacturing titanium ship hull structures. Using lower cost marine grades of titanium, they fabricated a 20-foot-long main deck panel—composed of six titanium plates, joined together by friction stir welding—as part of technology studies for an experimental naval vessel called Transformable Craft , or T-Craft.

Since antiquity, blacksmiths have joined iron or steel parts together by heating them in a forge, placing them on an anvil and striking the two pieces repeatedly with a heavy hammer. After several repetitions of heating and striking, the two pieces were “hammer forged” or “forge welded” together.

Friction stir welding joins metals using the heat of friction produced by a spinning pin tool pressed down on both pieces of metal at their common joint. Friction heating produced by the high-speed rotation causes both metal pieces to heat up to a “plastic” condition, but not to melt. As the tool passes down the common joint line, the heated, plasticized metal from both pieces is kneaded together in the rotating tool’s wake, forming the weld between them.

How it was accomplished

Friction stir welding works well for most aluminum alloys. Titanium, however, is difficult to join by the same process because of the high temperatures required, and pin tool materials that erode and react with titanium, weakening the weld.

The researchers overcame that problem by using new titanium friction stir welding methods developed by Florida-based Keystone Synergistic Enterprises Inc . with funding from both ONR and the Air Force . The processes were scaled up and transferred to the National Center for Advanced Manufacturing  (NCAM), which is a partnership between the University of New Orleans , NASA  and the state of Louisiana.

To fabricate the ship hull structure, more than 70 feet of welded linear joints were made—the longest known welds in titanium made with the friction stir process. This friction stir welding achievement showed a noticeable improvement from previous similar processes. It was made at a high linear speed—indicating reduced manufacturing time; showed excellent weld penetration—indicating a secure connection; and had no distortion of the titanium adjoining the weld.

Experts attribute the success to an effective design of the pin tool, process parameters that emphasized pin tool life and exact duplication of the process steps from facility to facility and machine to machine.

ONR funds collaborative projects investigating novel shipbuilding materials and improved processes for titanium friction stir welding—especially its affordability—as part of the Sea Base Enabler  Innovative Naval Prototype program.