Sept. 9, 2020
Gen. John E. Hyten
GENERAL JOHN E. HYTEN: Greetings. It’s General John
Hyten. I’m vice chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff. Thank you very
much for allowing me to be with you today talking about artificial
intelligence. It is a subject of much interest in the world. It’s been
a subject of my interest for quite a while now, and I’m going to share
some thoughts with you today about that subject.
So thanks very much for this conference. Thanks to the JAIC for
holding this conference. I really hope to get across and visit the JAIC
before long, but COVID has gotten in the way of that. COVID is also
the reason why we’re having to do this virtually. This would be much
better as a conversation, because I think this is a subject where we
need to learn from each other and delivering a speech, a lecture,
whatever you want to call this through a video is not the best way to
talk about artificial intelligence. Nonetheless, I’m going to do my
best to deliver some things for you to think about as we go forward.
So the first thing I want to do when I’m talking about artificial
intelligence is I want to share with you a quote, and it’s one of my
favorite quotes. It’s from John Kennedy. Now, the quote is about
space, and most people in the audience know that I’m a space officer,
have been a space officer for a lot of years. But what you may not know
is that’s not how I started my Air Force career. I started my Air
Force career as a software engineer, and I was a software engineer and a
– and a programmer, and that was how I started my Air Force career.
But I moved quickly into space because space has been my passion for a
long time.
So I’m going to share a quote with you, a quote that John Kennedy
gave in 1962 at Rice University. It’s not maybe his most well-known
quote, but it says a lot and I just want you to think about artificial
intelligence in context of this instead of space. But the quote goes
like this: “We set sail on this new sea because there is new knowledge
that must be gained, and new rights to be won, and they must be won and
used for the progress of all people. For space science, like nuclear
science and technology, has no conscience of its own. Whether it will
become a force for good or ill depends on man, and only if the United
States occupies a position of preeminence can we help decide whether
this new ocean will be a sea of peace or a new terrifying theater of
war.”
So that was about the space program. And that speech was part of the
speech that actually generated the excitement in this country and said
we’ll land a man on the Moon by the end of the decade, which we did. It
started the Apollo Program. It got my dad involved in the Saturn
Program. It got me excited about space. It generated a lot of things.
But in it, the president – President Kennedy at the time – talked about
whether it will be a sea of peace or a theater or war, whether it will
be for good or ill, and it’s dependent on man.
And if you think about artificial intelligence, we’re being asked
that question today: Is it going to be a force of good or a force of
ill? And it’s all up to us. We get to make that decision because,
simply put, it’s just technology, but it’s technology that the world
understands is critically important. And because the world understands,
that means our competitors, our adversaries, understand that being able
to use and apply artificial intelligence in future military operations
is going to be critical to the success of those operations.
So we have to figure out how to lead the world in doing that. And we
have some challenges as we walk forward into that, challenges because
much of the work that is being done in artificial intelligence, much of
the technology, much of the research and development is not being done
by the Department of Defense. I’ve got to be involved in tremendous
research and development over my career. I’ve seen from the very
beginning the development of satellite-based navigation, GPS;
satellite-based timing, GPS. I’ve seen the development of an integrated
circuit, an integrated circuit really built by our laboratories, our
DOD laboratories. And we are investing enormous amounts of taxpayers’
dollars in looking at the research that will be required for us to
leverage artificial intelligence, and that’s important.
But as much as we’re investing, it’s orders of magnitude larger in
the industrial sector. I was talking to one of our industry partners
last week, talking about their research-and-development budget, and
their research-and-development budget was measured in the billions.
That’s one company, measured in the billions. If you look at all of the
companies and how much is being invested, our numbers pale in
comparison. The great inventions are going to come out of industry.
I was – I was in Silicon Valley visiting a small artificial
intelligence company. They label themselves an artificial intelligence
company. And I saw artificial intelligence algorithms already running,
working through the data challenges that they have, applying this in a
real business model and delivering capability in the commercial sector.
It already exists. We have to be able to take advantage of not only
that industry, but the research that’s going on on that side. We have
to be able to partner with them.
And I tell you, we don’t like to do that in the Department of
Defense. We like to think we’re still the big dog in the room, and in
this case we are not. Well, at best we’ll be a minority partner in the
research that has to go on, but it doesn’t mean that we can’t deliver
very, very critical capabilities. We’ll focus on applying the research
and development of others into the military business, because that’s not
what they do; that’s what we do.
But we have to get out of our own way in many cases and apply the
research and development of others to our problems, which means we have
to partner with them. Which means there has to be a business case that
we – that we partner with them with because other businesses don’t just
do things out of the goodness of their heart. Many are operated by
great Americans. Many love operating in this country, want to make sure
this country succeeds. But they’re a private business. They have to
be able to make money. So we have to figure out how to partner with
them, allow them to make money, and then apply the technologies into our
side.
And again, we don’t like to do this. We like to control things. We
like to have a focus on our research-and-development budget, how those
things are going on. That is – that is not enough to make sure that we
can get the job done, so we have to look at research and development a
little bit different.
And then we have to look at all elements of artificial intelligence
and we have to look at them effectively. And there’s basically seven
building blocks of artificial intelligence. I’m going to spend a few
minutes talking about each one just so you understand what they are. So
the seven are algorithms, data, software, computing, ethics, engagement
with industry, and international cooperation. Those are the seven
building blocks that we have to be able to deal with.
And I tell you, when people come into my office – whether it’s
government people, industry people, whoever it is – it’s like, all they
talk about is algorithms. And don’t get me wrong, algorithms are
critical. Algorithms are important. But algorithms, to me, are
actually one of the easier problems to solve. We have to invest in
developing the algorithms, but there’s industry partners out there that
already have functioning algorithms that can take massive amounts of
data, apply the algorithms to the data, and learn from that – allow the
machine to learn from that, allow it to grow as we go through that. We
have to figure out how to do that and take advantage of those
algorithms, develop our own algorithms. But algorithms without the
other building blocks are useless, especially when it comes to data and
computing.
So of the seven building blocks I talked about just a while ago, the two most important are data and computing.
We have to make sure we focus on data. So I’ve talked a little bit
about algorithms. Again, we need to invest in algorithm development.
We need to understand what those are. We need to make sure we apply
them to the mission space that we have. But we really need to spend a
lot of time focusing on data. And there’s really two different pieces
of the data, and it’s actually related to computing as well.
The first thing we need to think about when it comes to data is
gathering all the data that exists so we can take advantage of it.
There is so much data that’s out there, and much of that data that we
gather in the Department of Defense we actually throw away. We just
ignore it because it’s irrelevant. Or the data is in the wrong format,
therefore it’s unusable to our structure. All of those things are
untrue.
I watched a company in California take data in a format that they’d
never seen before and they did not try to reformat the data. They just
taught the machine how to look at the data, understand the data, put it
in their construct so they could apply their algorithms to that data,
and with a couple weeks and just a couple hundred thousand dollars they
delivered a capability that just – that just blew me away because their
focus was on the data that existed. How do I – how do I learn from that
data? How do I understand that data? How do I take it? So the
structure and the format, we’ve tried for years to mandate a structure,
to mandate a format. That’s not the critical piece. We have to
understand how it is structured, how it is formatted. We have to
understand and be able to explain to others how to do that. But
machines can learn from that now if we just teach the machine to look
for the right kind of data. So we have to build that existing data
architecture out and understand what that is from the existing data that
is already out there in enormous amounts.
And then we have to look at data from a new perspective. Call it
data discovery. And in many cases, the machine that we’re talking about
– the machine that will be performing artificial intelligence, the
machine that will be learning as we go through this – that machine can
drive sensors all by itself. That machine, that computer, can have
sensors built into it, and it can gather that real time, discover new
information – discover that information, translate it into data, put
that data in the system, and learn from that data. So when you
integrate the sensing capability with the data, now, if you apply
computing in the right way, you can accomplish just amazing things.
So you see, computing, algorithms, and data together are all part of
the same puzzle. They can’t be looked at separately. They have to be
looked at together. And there’s two kinds of data – data that exists
and data that can be discovered – and we have to figure out how to work
in both of those. And then the computing has to be powerful enough and
fast enough to manipulate the data quickly, to pull the right
information so that we can deliver the kind of capabilities that we need
as we go forward to the future. That’s what we’re going to get out of
machine learning. That’s what we’re going to get out of artificial
intelligence.
So embedded in all that is the third element, and I kind of skipped
over that. I skipped over it intentionally. I talked about
algorithms. I talked about data. I talked about computing. But the
third element is software, because software is actually the magic that
is going to make all this happen. Somebody has to sit down and write
the code, figure out how to make all of this work together, how to make
sure we can look at the code and pull those things out. The software
developers of the future will be – will be the most important element of
this from a skill set because that is the art. The data is kind of an
enabling capability. The computer is the machine. The algorithms are
the magic. But the software that puts it all together is going to be
the key.
And when you look at software in the Department of Defense, oh my
gosh, we develop software in archaic, ridiculous, 20th-century ways that
never worked. And I’ve been through so many different
software-development approaches inside the Department of Defense. I was
part of the Ada Initiative, where the Department of Defense thought it
would be a brilliant idea to develop our own programming language so
that we could lead the world and teach ourselves how to write a common
programming language. Well, guess what? The Department of Defense does
not lead the world in software development. The rest of the world has
gone past us so many ways. And the developers are completely different.
When we put a software-development team together, what do we do? We
build it like – we build it like a tank. We build it like a ship. We
build it like an airplane or a satellite. We put together hundreds of
people and we put together these giant engineering teams and try to put
them together. That is not the way software is built in today’s day and
age. I have – I have relatives, I have friends, I have a number of
classmates and others that are heavily involved in the
software-development business, and they would never have a
software-development team with 500 people. We have software-development
teams with 500 people all over the department. It’s crazy. You have
to be nimble. You have to be fast. And you can’t be nimble and fast if
you have to integrate the work of 500 different programmers. It’s
literally impossible, and we will chase that to the end of the ages and
never be able to get to the answer. And you’re seeing that happens in
weapons system after weapons system, where we wait year after year for
the software to deliver. And we have to figure out how to do that
across our enterprise.
But when it comes to AI, we had better figure out how to do it in a
modern, quick way. Now, I use the word “quick” because it’s really
about speed. In order for us to stay abreast of our adversaries and
move ahead of our adversaries, we have to be able to move faster than
our adversaries. And right now the United States, actually, as a whole
does pretty well. If you go to Silicon Valley or Seattle or Cambridge,
or even here in the Washington, D.C. area, or you go to Austin, or you
go to any area where software development is a key piece – and our
nation moves unbelievably fast. If you go in the AI industry,
unbelievably fast. If you go in the Department of Defense, unbelievably
slow. Unbelievably slow. And for the life of me I cannot figure out
how we change that culture, that understanding, to move in a different
direction towards the future.
Now, I tell you, I have the term “culture” and I just used it. And I
used it for a reason, because many of you think that’s the Department
of Defense culture – that that’s just the way it is, and we have to
figure out how to deal with the culture. But I had a boss of mine once
who, when I gave a magnificent speech about the difficulty of culture
and changing culture, looked at me – and I was a general officer – and
he said: So, John, what is your rank? I said, general officer. And he
said, well, what is your duty title. I said, commander. He said,
well, how come you just don’t decide what it is your want to do, tell
your people you want to do it, and you’ll be amazed that people will
actually try to do this.
So what I’m asking this community – this community in artificial
intelligence, this community in the Department of Defense – is to
understand that speed is the critical piece of this entire process. We
have to figure out how to move fast in this area, and putting together
teams of hundreds of people writing code all at the same time will never
allow us to move fast. We have to put together small teams, small
teams that are integrated at the – at a broad strategic level that we
move quickly with. We develop products. If they work, we use them
quickly. If they don’t work, we throw them away and we move on.
It’s a completely different way of doing business, and we have to be
able to do that because if we can’t right-code that way we’ll never
fully embrace what artificial intelligence is doing. And the key is you
have to understand what artificial intelligence is, in China, in
Russia. But China in particular. They have identified that as a
critical issue, along with quantum, along with space and cyber and a
number of different areas. But artificial intelligence is a key piece,
and they’re moving incredibly quickly. They’re educating themselves in
China, they’re educating themselves in the United States, and they’re
moving unbelievably fast. And if doesn’t matter how far ahead you are;
if somebody’s running faster than you are, they’re eventually going to
pass you in the race. And you have to consider that we are in a
competition right now, and the goal of a competition is to win – not to
lose, to win. Which mean we have to move fast and we have to move fast
again. But we are challenged right now in figuring out how to move
fast.
So everybody in this crowd should be excited about working in the AI
world. They should be excited about the potential of machine learning.
They should be excited about the ability to integrate computing and
data and algorithms and software to develop capabilities that can
provide the United States enormous advantages as we move into the
future. But if we continue to do business the way we’ve been doing, we
will not be successful. We have to do business differently. So I ask
for your help in figuring out how to do that.
Then the fifth element. The fifth element is ethics, because there’s
a lot of challenges about what do we do with artificial intelligence in
warfare. And one of the first times I spoke in public about artificial
intelligence it was at Halifax, at the defense conference in Nova
Scotia, and I was on an evening panel – not really a panel, but just two
of us, Eric Schmidt of Alphabet/Google and me, standing up, talking
about the ethics of artificial intelligence in warfare. And if you’re
sitting next to or standing next to Eric Schmidt talking about that
topic, you have to realize that you are by far not the smartest person
in the room; he is. How, then, do I make the point?
And so I decided to start with the John Kennedy quote I started with
earlier because I think that describes exactly what we’re talking
about. And what it describes is it’s choice. Just like every other
technology this country has developed, it all goes back to – every
technology that’s ever been applied to warfare, from the rifle to the
tank to the airplane to the satellite, whether it’s a force of good or a
force of ill depends on man. It depends on how we use it. And it will
be the same way for artificial intelligence.
So my broad ethical look at artificial intelligence is that
artificial intelligence should never be used to start a war, ever.
Those decisions can only be made by humans. So the men and women that
lead our country – the men and women that lead the country, they have to
make the decision whether the country will use armed force to achieve
our political objectives. And if we’re attacked, I guarantee you that
we will use armed force to stand up for our – for our nation. We have
always done that and we always will. So the decision to go into a
conflict cannot be based on artificial intelligence; it has to be based
on human intelligence and the human decision process.
But once we’ve made the decision, then we have to be all in to
achieve our objectives, all in to achieve victory in that conflict. And
that comes from, in many ways, applying all technologies to our
advantage, which means applying artificial intelligence as well. And we
should not shy away from that. We should embrace that, understand it.
And if it gives us an advantage we need to figure out how to use it,
use it in the right way, make sure we use it within the elements of the
law of armed conflict, which should not be difficult to do. We’ve
figured it out with every other technology we’ve ever built, and we’ll
figure it out with artificial intelligence as well. It is just another
technology.
And then we have to make sure we engage with industry, and it’s a
different industry in many cases. I talked about that earlier when I
talked about the research-and-development challenges, but the industry
here is fundamentally different than the industry that we’ve dealt with
forever. It’s not just the Lockheeds, the Northrops, and Boeing.
They’ll be involved in this, don’t get me wrong, but it’s different
companies. And you have to reach out to those companies that actually
do this and actually understand it, and you have to partner with them.
You have to figure out how to contract with them, how to build those
capabilities, how to bring them in. And many of them don’t like doing
business with the Department of Defense because we are difficult to deal
with. The paperwork that we make a contractor fill out in order to do
business with this department is just outrageous in many cases. But we
have to figure out how to do that.
So you have to figure out how to, one, cut through the red tape, but
if there is red tape that has to be done figure out how to do it,
because we need the full breadth of industry. Because I remember five
years ago people said by 2020 China would be ahead of us in artificial
intelligence. I don’t think they are. I don’t think they’re ahead of
us here in 2020. But it’s not necessarily because of the work that’s
going on in the JAIC. That’s part of it, but it’s the work that’s going
on across this entire country. All of our industry is involved in
that, and that’s what’s keeping our advantage. So we, the Department of
Defense, have to figure out how to leverage all of industry.
And then we have to figure out how to do this with our allies and our
partners. And our allies and partners have to be with us every step of
the way because whatever conflict we get into in the future, wherever
it happens, whenever it happens, the one – the biggest advantage the
United States has is that we go in with friends, we go in with our
allies and partners. And so we can’t close the door right from the
beginning to our allies and partners. We have to bring them in, make
sure they understand exactly what they’re doing. They’re also investing
large amounts in artificial intelligence. We have partnerships with
many of them already developed and we’re – and we’re moving ahead with
pace, which is good. But we have to figure out how to take advantage of
that friendship, that alliance, those partners, in order to make sure
that when we move forward in the future we’re ready to do it together.
Right now we’re about to deliver to the secretary of defense a new
Joint Warfighting Concept. That Joint Warfighting Concept will be
delivered by the end of the year. And so I know that the – many of the
folks here in the Pentagon, folks on the Joint Staff get nervous when I
say we’re about ready to deliver because it’s not done yet and we’re
still going through the experimentation phase. But if we’re going to
deliver in December, which we’ve promised the secretary we’d do, we have
to actually deliver a product and we have to make decisions on what
that product’s going to be. We have to experiment, understand, and
learn, but we’re going to deliver that. And December is only about four
months away, so we’re about there. And we’re starting to understand
what that really is.
And the amazing thing about that Joint Warfighting Concept is it –
the fundamentals of it is it eliminates all the lines on the battlefield
that we’ve dealt with our entire lives. So for almost 40 years in the
military, I’ve dealt with fire-support coordination lines and forward
edge of the battle area and all of these lines. I’ve dealt with
killboxes. I’ve dealt with all these structures where we say this is
the area that the Navy can operate in, this is the area that the Air
Force can operate in, this is the area the Army can operate in. And
those lines are going to go away because we’re going to be able to bring
fires from all domains, including space and cyber, kinetic and
non-kinetic. We’ll be able to bring fires from all domains seamlessly.
And the speed which we do that will overwhelm and adversary –
overwhelm an adversary and hopefully create the environment where we no
longer have to worry about fighting that war because an adversary will
look at us and say I never want to enter into war with the United
States. That is deterrence, having a capability that prevents the war
from happening. And goodness knows we never want to have a war with
China or a war with Russia or a war with any nuclear-armed adversary,
and the only way to avoid that is to have such strength that is
demonstrated to our adversaries that they will not challenge us. We can
do that.
And you can see that if we go into a future where there are no lines
on the battlefield, and we have ubiquitous all-domain command and
control and logistics that go seamlessly from place to place, from
service to service, and it all happens in enormous speed, holy cow, that
is the world where an adversary will not challenge us. Therefore, we
have to figure out how are we going to do that. And I’d tell you I
can’t figure out in my mind how to do that without artificial
intelligence. And when I talk about that, the Joint Warfighting
Concept, I realize we left off a critical element because it actually
should be a Combined Joint Warfighting Concept, because we have to bring
on our allies and partners.
So it has to be enabled by artificial intelligence. We have to be
able to use machine learning to create that environment. An all-domain
command-and-control concept has to have all those pieces together, and
we have to have our allies and partners with us. That’s the key to
moving forward.
And how many times in this remark – and you can go back and look at
the tape if you want, since it’s taped – how many times have I said,
that’s the key? At least five times I’ve said that’s the key because
all of these things have to be linked together. All of this has to come
together. But when it does, that’s when we have a concept that will
deter our adversaries and prevent major-power conflict.
So I’m going to read that quote to you one more time but I’m going to
change one word. So: “We set sail on this new sea because there is
new knowledge to be gained, and new rights to be won, and they must be
won and used for the progress of all people. For artificial
intelligence, like nuclear science and technology, has no conscience of
its own. Whether it will become a force for good or ill depends on man,
and only if the United States occupies a position of preeminence can we
help decide whether this new ocean will be a sea of peace or a new
terrifying theater of war.”
We want peace on this planet. We want peace to be the world that our
children live in. That’s the world we want. That’s what we need to
use all of our capabilities for, and artificial intelligence is one of
those.
So I look forward to working together with you to achieve this kind
of vision. This is a complicated process. Hopefully, today I’ve given
you a few things to think about as you begin this conference or as you
continue this conference. And again, as you see me in the hallways, or
feel free to send me an email, because this shouldn’t be just a speech;
this should be a discussion. And I look forward to that discussion
continuing. Thank you very much.